Calculator

HSA and FSA Savings Calculator for Dental Work

See roughly how much paying a dental bill with pre-tax HSA or FSA money could save you, from the tax rates you enter.

Payroll tax (Social Security and Medicare) is 7.65% for most employees; enter 0 if you are self-employed or want to ignore it. Some states do not follow federal treatment of HSAs; enter your own state rate or 0.

Estimate

Estimated tax savings
-
Net cost after savings
-
Combined rate used
-

How the estimate works

The estimate multiplies the expense by your combined rate: federal and state income tax, plus payroll tax where the contribution is made through pay. An FSA is funded through an employer plan with pre-tax pay. An HSA funded through payroll also avoids payroll tax, while one funded directly is generally deductible for income tax but not for payroll tax, so the tool drops the payroll rate for that choice. It assumes you would otherwise pay the expense with after-tax money and that your marginal rates do not change. It is an illustration, not a tax return.

A worked example

With a $2,000 dental bill, a 22% federal rate, a 5% state rate and 7.65% payroll tax, an FSA or a payroll-funded HSA gives a combined rate of 34.65%, so the estimated saving is about $693 and the net cost about $1,307. Funding an HSA directly drops the payroll tax, giving 27% and a saving of about $540. The defaults in the form above are this example.

Questions people ask

Which dental costs qualify?

IRS Publication 969 says FSA-qualifying expenses are generally those that qualify for the medical and dental expense deduction, and Publication 502 lists cleanings, sealants, fluoride, X-rays, fillings, braces, extractions and dentures. It excludes teeth whitening.

Is the saving guaranteed?

No. It depends on your actual tax situation, your plan's rules and whether you would have paid the bill anyway. A tax professional can tell you what applies to you.

Why does the account type change the result?

Pay-based contributions can avoid payroll tax as well as income tax, while a direct HSA contribution is generally deductible for income tax only. Your state may also treat HSAs differently, so enter your own state rate.

Rules and limits to check

Our post on dental FSA, HSA and tax deduction rules sets out what the IRS publications say, and our year-end benefits post covers plan deadlines. Ask your plan administrator for your deadline and a tax professional about your own situation.